Want Top Dollar? Hire a Listing Agent Who Does THIS
Most homeowners think all real estate agents do the same thing.
Put a sign in the yard.
Take a few photos.
Put the home on the MLS.
Wait for offers.
And while that may have worked in certain markets years ago, today’s real estate market is different.
The truth is that the difference between an average listing agent and a great listing agent can literally mean thousands—or even tens of thousands—of dollars in your pocket.
After helping homeowners sell homes for more than 13 years, I’ve seen it happen over and over again. Two similar homes. Same neighborhood. Similar condition. One sells quickly with multiple offers and excellent terms. The other sits on the market, gets price reductions, and ultimately sells for less.
The difference?
The agent.
If your goal is to get top dollar for your home, here’s what you should be looking for when hiring a listing agent.
They Start With Strategy, Not a Sales Pitch
One of the biggest mistakes sellers make is choosing the agent who promises the highest price.
It sounds good in the living room.
It feels good in the moment.
But it often ends badly.
A few years ago, I met with a homeowner whose home had been on the market for nearly six months with another agent. The previous agent told them exactly what they wanted to hear and listed the home significantly above market value.
The problem?
Buyers didn’t agree.
After months of showings, frustration, and multiple price reductions, the sellers were exhausted.
When we sat down together, we looked at the data, created a realistic pricing strategy, repositioned the home in the market, and generated strong activity almost immediately.
The home sold shortly afterward.
Great listing agents don’t tell you what you want to hear.
They tell you what you need to know.
Pricing Is Marketing
Most sellers think pricing is about determining value.
It’s actually about creating demand.
Price too high and buyers ignore your listing.
Price too low and you leave money on the table.
Price it correctly and you create competition.
Competition creates leverage.
Leverage creates better offers.
Better offers create more money in your pocket.
That’s the goal.
They Invest in Professional Marketing
Here’s a simple truth:
Your home gets judged online before anyone ever walks through the front door.
Today’s buyers scroll through hundreds of listings on their phones.
If your home doesn’t stop their thumb, it doesn’t get a showing.
And if it doesn’t get a showing, it doesn’t get an offer.
Professional Photography Matters
I still see listings with dark photos, crooked angles, poor lighting, and blurry images.
It amazes me.
You’re selling one of your largest assets.
Professional photography shouldn’t be optional.
The best listing agents hire professional photographers because they understand that first impressions matter.
Video Is No Longer a Luxury
Video allows buyers to emotionally connect with a property.
They can imagine themselves living there.
Hosting holidays there.
Drinking coffee on the back patio.
Watching their kids play in the yard.
People buy emotionally and justify logically.
Video helps create that emotional connection.
Social Media Exposure Creates More Demand
A great listing agent doesn’t simply place your home on the MLS and hope someone finds it.
They actively market the property through:
- YouTube
- Email marketing
- Neighborhood campaigns
- Agent networks
The more eyeballs on your home, the better your chances of attracting the right buyer.
They Know How to Prepare a Home for Sale
One of my favorite conversations with sellers is helping them see their home through a buyer’s eyes.
Most homeowners have lived in their property for years.
They stop noticing things.
The worn paint.
The crowded countertops.
The overstuffed closets.
The family photos covering every wall.
Buyers notice everything.
Small Changes Can Create Big Returns
I’ve seen sellers spend a few hundred dollars on paint, landscaping, and decluttering and add thousands to their final sales price.
Not because the home became perfect.
Because it became more appealing.
Buyers don’t need perfection.
They need confidence.
A great listing agent helps create that confidence before buyers ever step through the door.
Staging Sells
Think of staging as packaging.
Apple doesn’t sell phones in cardboard boxes.
Luxury retailers don’t display products on folding tables.
Presentation matters.
Homes are no different.
Even simple staging adjustments can dramatically improve buyer perception and help generate stronger offers.
They Are Skilled Negotiators
Most people focus on commission.
Very few focus on negotiation skills.
That’s a mistake.
Because negotiation often has a much larger impact on your bottom line than the commission itself.
The Offer Is Only the Beginning
When an offer comes in, many sellers think the hard part is over.
In reality, the negotiation is just beginning.
Inspection issues.
Appraisal challenges.
Repair requests.
Closing timelines.
Contingencies.
All of these can impact how much money you ultimately walk away with.
A skilled listing agent knows when to push.
When to compromise.
And when to protect your interests.
One Conversation Can Save Thousands
I’ve had situations where a single negotiation conversation saved my clients thousands of dollars.
Not because I was aggressive.
Because I was prepared.
The best negotiators aren’t emotional.
They’re strategic.
And strategy wins.
They Communicate Constantly
One of the biggest complaints consumers have about real estate agents is poor communication.
Nothing creates stress faster than wondering what’s happening with one of your biggest financial assets.
A great listing agent keeps you informed every step of the way.
You Should Never Feel Left in the Dark
You deserve updates about:
- Showing activity
- Buyer feedback
- Market changes
- Marketing performance
- New competition
Communication creates confidence.
Confidence reduces stress.
And selling a home is stressful enough already.
The right agent helps make the process feel manageable.
They Have a Proven Track Record
Past performance doesn’t guarantee future results.
But it does provide clues.
Before hiring an agent, ask questions.
Ask These Questions
How many homes have you sold recently?
What is your average days on market?
What percentage of list price do your listings typically sell for?
Can I read your reviews?
Can you show me examples of your marketing?
A professional agent should be able to answer these questions confidently and provide proof.
Results matter.
Systems matter.
Experience matters.
Beware of These Red Flags
Not every agent who gets licensed becomes a great listing agent.
Watch out for these warning signs:
They Promise an Unrealistic Price
If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.
They Can’t Explain Their Marketing Plan
“Putting it on the MLS” isn’t a marketing strategy.
It’s the minimum requirement.
They Immediately Discount Their Commission
If someone negotiates against themselves before the job starts, how hard will they negotiate for you later?
They Focus on Themselves
Great agents focus on your goals, your concerns, and your outcomes—not on impressing you with their accomplishments.
The Bottom Line
If you want top dollar for your home, don’t hire an agent because they’re your cousin, your neighbor, or the cheapest option available.
Hire an agent who:
- Prices strategically
- Markets aggressively
- Prepares your home properly
- Negotiates skillfully
- Communicates consistently
- Has a proven track record
Because at the end of the day, selling a home isn’t about getting the highest list price.
It’s about getting the highest net proceeds with the least amount of stress.
The right listing agent doesn’t cost you money.
They make you money.
And that’s a difference worth paying attention to.
Ready to take the next step? Reach out to the Reliance Real Estate Team today!
https://www.reliancerealestateteam.com/contact/
414-659-6965 / jsingsheim@kw.com
If you’d rather listen instead of read, check me out on Spotify:
🎧 Listen on Spotify or Listen on Apple Podcast
Perfect for your commute, workout, or coffee break!
#RealEstateTips #PodcastLife #HomeSellingAdvice #HomeBuyingTips #RealtorLife #WisconsinRealEstate #MilwaukeeRealEstate #WaukeshaCounty