What Sellers Should Demand From Their Real Estate Agent
The Non-Negotiables Every Homeowner Needs to Know Before Hiring an Agent
Selling a home is one of the biggest financial decisions most people will ever make. Yet many homeowners spend more time researching a new television than they do researching the person responsible for helping them sell what is often their largest asset.
I’ve been helping homeowners buy and sell real estate for more than a decade, and if there’s one thing I’ve learned, it’s this:
The right agent can make you thousands of dollars. The wrong one can cost you thousands.
In today’s market, simply putting a sign in the yard and uploading photos to the MLS isn’t enough. Buyers are smarter. Competition is tougher. Marketing has changed. Negotiation matters more than ever.
Whether you’re planning to sell next month or next year, here are the things every homeowner should demand from their real estate agent.
Demand a Real Marketing Plan
A Sign in the Yard Is Not a Marketing Strategy
Years ago, a home could sell simply because it was on the MLS.
Today? Not so much.
Most buyers begin their search online. They scroll through listings while sitting on their couch, waiting in line at Starbucks, or during halftime of a football game. If your home doesn’t stop their scroll, you may never get the showing.
One of the biggest mistakes I see homeowners make is assuming all agents market homes the same way.
They don’t.
A professional marketing plan should include:
- Professional photography
- Video walkthroughs
- Social media exposure
- Email marketing
- Open house strategies
- Buyer database promotion
- Targeted online advertising
A Quick Story
A few years ago, I met with a homeowner whose previous listing had expired.
The home had been on the market for months with little activity.
When I looked at the previous marketing, the photos were dark, poorly framed, and taken with what looked like an older cell phone.
We invested in professional photography, created a strategic marketing plan, and repositioned the property.
The result?
The home sold.
Same house. Different presentation.
Marketing matters.
Demand Honest Pricing Advice
Beware of the Agent Who Promises the Highest Price
This may surprise you, but one of the biggest red flags isn’t an agent who suggests a lower price.
It’s the one who tells you exactly what you want to hear.
Every seller wants top dollar. I get it.
But pricing isn’t about wishful thinking. It’s about market reality.
Some agents “buy the listing” by recommending an inflated price just to secure your signature.
Then three weeks later, they start talking about price reductions.
Sound familiar?
The Truth About Pricing
The market determines value.
Not Zillow.
Not your neighbor.
Not what you need to net.
Not what you spent on renovations.
Buyers compare your home against every other available option.
A great agent should be able to explain:
- Comparable sales
- Current competition
- Market trends
- Buyer demand
- Days on market
If they can’t explain how they arrived at their pricing recommendation, keep interviewing.
Demand Consistent Communication
The Number One Complaint About Real Estate Agents
Want to know what homeowners complain about most?
It’s not commissions.
It’s not marketing.
It’s communication.
People hate feeling forgotten.
They hate wondering whether anything is happening.
And they especially hate chasing their agent for updates.
What Good Communication Looks Like
A professional agent should provide:
- Showing feedback
- Market updates
- Weekly communication
- Strategy discussions
- Quick responses to questions
One thing I tell clients is this:
“I’d rather over-communicate than leave you guessing.”
Even when there’s no major news, knowing what’s happening creates confidence.
Silence creates anxiety.
Demand Strong Negotiation Skills
Selling Isn’t About Getting an Offer
It’s About Keeping One Together
Many people think negotiation only affects the purchase price.
In reality, negotiations happen throughout the transaction.
Inspection issues.
Repair requests.
Appraisal concerns.
Closing timelines.
Contingencies.
I’ve seen deals that looked perfect on paper fall apart because an agent didn’t know how to navigate difficult conversations.
A Lesson From Experience
I once represented sellers who received multiple offers.
The highest offer wasn’t actually the best offer.
The winning buyer had stronger financing, fewer contingencies, and a smoother path to closing.
Had we focused only on price, the sellers could have lost weeks of valuable time if the deal collapsed.
A skilled negotiator looks beyond the headline number.
They protect the entire transaction.
Demand Local Market Expertise
National Headlines Don’t Sell Your House
Every year I hear people quote national real estate statistics.
The problem?
Real estate is hyper-local.
What’s happening nationally may have little impact on your neighborhood.
Your market could be:
- Appreciating faster
- Slowing down
- Experiencing inventory shortages
- Seeing increased buyer demand
A local expert understands:
- Neighborhood trends
- School district influence
- Buyer preferences
- Seasonal shifts
- Competitive positioning
The internet can provide information.
Experience provides context.
Demand Proof, Not Promises
Trust But Verify
Every agent claims they work hard.
Every agent says they provide great service.
The question is:
Can they prove it?
Before hiring anyone, look at:
- Google reviews
- Zillow reviews
- Social media presence
- Testimonials
- Recent sales history
What Reviews Tell You
Reviews reveal patterns.
Do clients consistently mention communication?
Marketing?
Negotiation?
Problem solving?
One glowing review is nice.
Fifty consistent reviews tell a story.
Look for evidence, not marketing slogans.
Demand Professional Photography and Video
Buyers Fall in Love Online First
Before buyers schedule a showing, they form an opinion.
And they do it quickly.
Professional photography is no longer optional.
It’s expected.
The difference between professional photography and amateur photos can mean:
- More online views
- More showings
- Better offers
- Faster sales
Think about it this way:
If luxury car manufacturers invested in poor photography, how many cars would they sell?
Your home deserves professional presentation too.
Demand a Customized Strategy
Every Seller’s Situation Is Different
Not every homeowner is selling for the same reason.
Some are:
- Downsizing
- Relocating
- Going through divorce
- Managing an estate
- Selling an expired listing
- Buying and selling simultaneously
The strategy should reflect your goals.
An agent who uses the same approach for every seller is like a doctor prescribing the same medication for every patient.
Your circumstances matter.
Your timeline matters.
Your goals matter.
Demand a plan designed specifically for you.
Demand Transparency
No Surprises
One of the fastest ways to lose trust is through unexpected surprises.
Your agent should clearly explain:
- Commission structure
- Marketing investments
- Closing costs
- Expected timelines
- Potential challenges
A good professional doesn’t hide difficult conversations.
They have them early.
The more you understand upfront, the smoother the transaction becomes.
Demand a Backup Plan
Hope Is Not a Strategy
Every home seller wants immediate showings and multiple offers.
Sometimes that happens.
Sometimes it doesn’t.
That’s why great agents prepare for multiple scenarios.
Ask this question:
“What happens if we don’t get the activity we expect?”
The answer will tell you a lot.
Professional agents adjust.
They analyze data.
They make strategic changes.
They don’t simply hope things improve.
Red Flags That Should Make You Think Twice
If you’re interviewing agents, watch for these warning signs:
The Agent Who:
- Promises the highest price without evidence
- Has no written marketing plan
- Can’t explain market statistics
- Takes days to return calls
- Has very few reviews
- Pressures you to sign immediately
- Focuses entirely on themselves instead of your goals
Trust your instincts.
If something feels off during the interview process, it usually doesn’t improve after you sign.
Final Thoughts
The reality is simple.
You’re not hiring someone to put a sign in your yard.
You’re hiring someone to market one of your largest assets, negotiate on your behalf, guide you through major decisions, and help you maximize your outcome.
The difference between an average agent and a great one isn’t measured by how many homes they sell.
It’s measured by how they serve their clients.
Before you choose an agent, ask tough questions.
Request proof.
Demand a strategy.
And remember: the cheapest mistake you’ll ever make is interviewing multiple agents before deciding who gets the job.
Because when it comes to selling your home, the right professional can make all the difference.
Ready to take the next step? Reach out to the Reliance Real Estate Team today!
https://www.reliancerealestateteam.com/contact/
414-659-6965 / jsingsheim@kw.com
If you’d rather listen instead of read, check me out on Spotify:
🎧 Listen on Spotify or Listen on Apple Podcast
Perfect for your commute, workout, or coffee break!
#RealEstateTips #PodcastLife #HomeSellingAdvice #HomeBuyingTips #RealtorLife #WisconsinRealEstate #MilwaukeeRealEstate #WaukeshaCounty